Skip to Content

Why did I lose weight after eating more?


Losing weight while eating more may seem counterintuitive, but it can happen for several reasons. Some potential causes include:

  • Increasing muscle mass – More food provides more calories to build muscle while burning fat.
  • Healthier food choices – You may be eating more volume while consuming fewer calories.
  • Correcting metabolic issues – Eating more can help correct metabolic dysfunctions that cause weight gain.
  • Improved gut health – A better microbiome through prebiotic foods enhances metabolism.
  • Reducing stress and poor sleep – More food reduces stress hormones and improves sleep quality.

While weight loss comes down to being in a calorie deficit, the composition of your diet plays a major role. Eating more of the right foods can promote weight loss. Let’s explore the science behind why eating more could lead to losing weight.

Increasing Muscle Mass

Building lean muscle is one of the main reasons some people lose weight when they increase their food intake. Muscle tissue burns more calories than fat tissue – about 3x more per pound.

When you eat in a calorie surplus while strength training, your body can utilize those extra calories to synthesize new muscle proteins for growth and repair. This enhances your resting metabolic rate, meaning you burn more calories around the clock.

Here are some of the key mechanisms by which eating more helps build muscle and boost metabolism:

  • Provides amino acids to synthesize muscle proteins
  • Fuels energy for intensive training
  • Spikes protein synthesis through leucine
  • Increases anabolic hormones like insulin and testosterone
  • Reduces muscle breakdown between workouts

To build muscle while losing fat, aim for a slight calorie surplus of around 10-20%, paired with consistent strength training. Focus on sufficient protein intake, about 0.7-1g per pound of body weight.

Case Study: Bulking Diet for Muscle Growth

Here is an example case study of how increasing calorie intake can promote muscle gains and fat loss:

Metrics Before Bulking After Bulking (12 weeks)
Weight 165 lbs 175 lbs
Body Fat % 18% 15%
Lean Mass 135 lbs 149 lbs

This individual aimed for a 300 calorie surplus and gained about 1 lb per week. Despite gaining weight, they lost 3% body fat by building muscle mass.

Healthier Food Choices

Sometimes you can eat a greater volume of food while still reducing overall calorie intake. This occurs when replacing processed, calorie-dense foods with more nutritious, satiating choices.

For example, 100 calories of broccoli contains a lot more food by volume than 100 calories of potato chips.

Here are some examples of lower calorie, high volume foods to include in a weight loss diet:

  • Non-starchy vegetables like greens, broccoli, peppers, etc.
  • Berries and other lower sugar fruits like grapefruit
  • Lean proteins like chicken breast, fish, tofu, eggs
  • Fiber-rich whole grains like oats, quinoa, bran
  • Legumes and beans including lentils, chickpeas, peas

Filling up on foods with fewer calories by volume lets you eat more food while reducing overall caloric intake. This increased satiety also helps reduce cravings and overeating.

Sample Day of Low Calorie Density Eating

Here is an example daily meal plan focused on low calorie density foods for weight loss:

Meal Foods Calories
Breakfast Oatmeal made with milk, blueberries, almonds 350
Lunch Mixed greens salad with chicken, avocado, dressing 450
Snack Carrots and hummus 200
Dinner Shrimp stir fry with veggies and brown rice 500
Totals 1500

As you can see, the meals and snacks are lower in calorie density yet provide significant volume. This supports weight loss while allowing satiating food intake.

Correcting Metabolic Issues

For some people, undereating and overly restrictive diets have damaged their metabolism over time. This can include reduced levels of key hormones like leptin that regulate appetite and body weight.

Increasing food intake from a very low baseline can help bring hormone levels back into balance. This corrects metabolic issues leading to easier weight loss over time.

Here are some of the main hormonal changes that occur when increasing intake after a highly restrictive diet:

  • Leptin increases – Signals to body to burn fat
  • Ghrelin decreases – Reduces appetite stimulation
  • Insulin stabilizes – Allows stored fat to be burned
  • Thyroid improves – Boosts metabolic rate

For those recovering from long periods of overly-low calorie diets, adding about 200-300 calories per day can improve hormone balance and metabolic function. This sets the stage for easier, more sustainable fat loss.

Phases of Metabolic Recovery

Here is an overview of the general phases involved in correcting metabolic damage from chronic dieting:

Phase Duration Goal
Baseline Diet Break 2-4 weeks Eat at maintenance calories
Metabolic Repair 8-12 weeks Slight calorie surplus with weight training
Sustainable Fat Loss Ongoing Moderate calorie deficit and lifestyle habits

The metabolic repair phase is where eating more plays a key role in improving hormone balance and losing weight long-term.

Improving Gut Health

The microbes in your digestive system, known as the gut microbiome, play an important role in regulating body weight and metabolism.

Eating more prebiotic fiber feeds the growth of beneficial gut bacteria. This can enhance weight loss in several ways:

  • Increases satiety signals to the brain
  • Produces short-chain fatty acids that boost metabolism
  • Lowers fat storage hormones like lipoprotein lipase
  • Reduces absorption of calories from food

Prebiotic foods that boost friendly bacteria include:

  • Onions, garlic, leeks
  • Apples, bananas, oranges
  • Beans, lentils, chickpeas
  • Oats, flaxseeds, almonds
  • Asparagus, carrots, sweet potatoes

Aim for getting 25-40 grams of prebiotic fiber per day. This feeds gut bacteria to enhance weight loss.

Prebiotic Foods to Improve Metabolism

Here is an example 1-day meal plan with about 35 grams of prebiotic fiber:

Meal Foods Prebiotic Fiber
Breakfast Oatmeal with bananas and almonds 10 grams
Lunch Chickpea salad sandwich 8 grams
Dinner Salmon with sweet potato and greens 12 grams
Snacks Apple, carrots, popcorn 5 grams
Totals 35 grams

Including a variety of prebiotic foods provides the fuel your gut bacteria need to enhance weight loss.

Reducing Stress and Poor Sleep

Chronic stress and poor sleep are linked to weight gain and difficulty losing weight. This is due to spikes in hormones like cortisol and glucose dysregulation.

Eating adequate food throughout the day provides energy and prevents hunger-induced stress. This reduces cortisol levels which tend to drive fat storage, especially around the abdomen.

Getting enough calories also supports restful sleep, which is essential for appetite control and metabolic health. Those lacking in sleep tend to experience more cravings for sugary and fatty foods.

Here are some of the ways reducing stress improves weight loss:

  • Lowers cortisol which increases belly fat
  • Stabilizes blood sugar to prevent insulin spikes
  • Reduces emotional eating of comfort foods
  • Enables exercise and meal planning consistency

While dieting itself can be stressful, eating adequate calories from nutritious whole foods provides energy, satisfaction, and better sleep quality. All of these benefits enhance weight loss results.

Daily Destress Routine

Here are some daily habits to build that can lower stress while supporting weight loss:

  • Get 7-9 hours of quality sleep per night
  • Practice mindful breathing for 10+ minutes
  • Take a 30 minute walk outdoors
  • Drink chamomile tea before bedtime
  • Write in a gratitude journal
  • Listen to relaxing music
  • Take relaxing bubble baths

By reducing stress and getting restorative sleep, you’ll be better equipped both mentally and physiologically to lose weight.

Conclusion

While losing weight comes down to eating fewer calories than you burn, the composition of your diet is crucial.

Increasing intake of satisfying, nutrient-dense whole foods can promote:

  • Muscle building
  • Appetite control
  • Metabolic improvements
  • Enhanced gut health
  • Reduced stress

All of these benefits can enable weight loss, even while eating greater food volume. Focus on quality over quantity by building meals from minimally processed foods.

With the right dietary composition, you can lose weight while eating more. A nutritious diet supports muscle building, metabolism, and appetite regulation for successful fat loss.