When it comes to protein powders, taste is a major consideration for many people. While there are plenty of delicious options available, finding one that specifically tastes like the iconic chocolate and peanut butter candy Reese’s can be a challenge. In this article, we’ll explore some of the protein powders on the market that come closest to mimicking the taste of Reese’s.
Why Finding a Reese’s-Flavored Protein Powder Matters
Reese’s peanut butter cups are one of the most popular candy choices in America. The combination of chocolate, peanut butter, and that distinctive ridge down the middle makes for an indulgent, crave-worthy treat. For those looking to add more protein to their diet or supplement their workouts, getting that nostalgic Reese’s flavor in a protein powder can help satisfy cravings for the candy. It also makes the supplement more enjoyable to drink on a regular basis.
Additionally, many dieters find that having flavors they love, like a chocolate peanut butter taste, helps them stick to their nutrition plans better. When you enjoy the way your protein powder tastes, you’re more likely to consume it consistently. Finding a protein supplement that mimics the Reese’s experience gives you the best of both worlds: muscle-friendly protein and a dessert-like flavor you love.
Key Characteristics of a Reese’s-Like Protein Powder
So what should you look for if you’re trying to find a protein powder resembling the taste of Reese’s candy? There are a few key characteristics the supplement should have:
- Chocolate and peanut butter flavors – The powder should contain cocoa or chocolate along with peanut flavoring or powdered peanut butter.
- Smooth, creamy texture – Like Reese’s, the powder when mixed should have a smooth, creamy mouthfeel.
- Sweetness – The cocoa flavoring should taste rich while the peanut butter adds nutty sweetness.
- Ability to mix into milk or water – For best flavor, it should mix easily into a milk-based liquid.
Bonus points if the powder smells like Reese’s when you open the tub! Keep these markers in mind as you search for a Reese’s protein powder match.
Top Protein Powder Picks for Reese’s Fans
After extensive research, these protein powders come closest to mimicking the chocolatey, peanut-buttery flavor of Reese’s candy:
1. Optimum Nutrition Double Rich Chocolate
Optimum Nutrition (ON) is one of the most popular protein supplement brands, known for its wide range of flavors. Their Double Rich Chocolate combines cocoa powder and chocolate flavoring for a fudgy taste. While it doesn’t contain peanut butter, fans say it provides a chocolate taste very similar to Reese’s when blended.
2. Pescience Select Protein Peanut Butter Cup
True to its name, Pescience’s Peanut Butter Cup flavor contains peanut flour and cocoa powder for an authentic Reese’s-like taste. Reviewers say it nails the candy’s chocolaty, nutty flavor. The texture is also smooth and creamy.
3. Rule 1 R1 Protein Powder Chocolate Peanut Butter
Rule 1 targets fans of candy flavors with options like Snickerdoodle and Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Their Chocolate Peanut Butter combines whey protein with natural cocoa powder and peanut flour. Customers report it tastes just like a melted Reese’s protein shake.
4. Transparent Labs Organic Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter
For plant-based protein, Transparent Lab’s vegan powder infuses chocolate and peanut butter flavors into brown rice protein. Reviewers call it “dangerously close” to tasting like real Reese’s. The creamy texture adds to the candy similarity.
Tips for Making Your Own Reese’s Protein Shake
If you can’t find a pre-made powder that fully satisfies your Reese’s craving, you can mix up your own custom protein shake. Here are some tips:
- Use a chocolate protein powder and add powdered peanut butter like PB2.
- Mix chocolate casein powder with chocolate almond milk for creaminess.
- Blend a scoop of vanilla protein powder with peanut butter, milk, cocoa powder, and a touch of honey.
- Top your shake with chopped Reese’s peanut butter cups or pieces.
- Go straight to the source and use Reese’s protein powder from the King himself!
Don’t be afraid to experiment with ingredients and ratios to create your ideal Reese’s protein shake. The boost of protein will satisfy your body while the flavor covers your chocolate peanut butter cravings.
The Best Protein Powder for Reese’s Fans
Based on taste test reviews and nutritional quality, the top protein powder pick for Reese’s fans is Pescience Select Protein in Peanut Butter Cup. Here’s a glance at some of its key features:
| Protein Powder | Key Features |
|---|---|
| Pescience Select Protein Peanut Butter Cup |
|
Reviews for Pescience’s Peanut Butter Cup flavor confirm it has an authentic Reese’s-like taste. The combination of high-quality whey protein, cocoa powder, and peanut flour mirror the candy’s chocolate and nutty flavor notes. It blends easily into shakes with a creamy consistency. Plus, it packs muscle-building BCAAs without any unhealthy additives.
Other Benefits of Reese’s-Flavored Protein Powders
Beyond satisfying sweet cravings, adding a Reese’s-style protein powder to your diet can provide other benefits as well. Here are some additional advantages:
- Convenience – Powder is easier to use on-the-go compared to making peanut butter sandwiches.
- Weight management – Protein is more filling than candy and can help manage hunger and cravings.
- Muscle growth – Leucine and BCAAs in whey protein stimulate muscle protein synthesis after workouts.
- Post-workout recovery – The protein helps repair and rebuild muscle tissue damaged during exercise.
- Nutrient supply – Provides calcium for bones, B vitamins for energy, iron for blood oxygenation, and more.
While Reese’s candies sure taste good, they provide little nutritional value. Protein powders give you a healthy way to indulge your chocolate peanut butter fix.
Potential Drawbacks of Reese’s Protein Powders
Are there any downsides associated with relying on Reese’s flavored powders? Here are a few potential cons to be aware of:
- May still contain processed ingredients like gums, coloring agents, etc.
- Could trigger cravings for actual Reese’s candies or other sweets.
- Some products use artificial sweeteners, which some people try to avoid.
- May not provide well-rounded nutrition without adding other ingredients like fruits.
- Higher calorie counts than unflavored protein options.
To avoid processed additives, try finding a powder that uses all natural flavorings. And limit portion sizes to keep calories in check. Drinking these shakes too often could lead to overindulgence in sugary treats.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Do Reese’s-flavored protein powders contain real peanut butter?
A: Most Reese’s protein powders use peanut flour rather than actual peanut butter. Peanut flour allows the peanut flavor to integrate more easily into the powder. Some powders also add powdered peanut butter like PB2 to provide even more authentic peanut taste.
Q: Are there Reese’s powders for weight loss?
A: Yes, some Reese’s-inspired powders aim to support weight loss. Options like BSN Syntha-6 Edge Chocolate Peanut Butter use protein to increase satiety. ISOFlex Chocolate Peanut Butter contains just 130 calories per serving. Just be mindful of portion size when using as a meal replacement.
Q: Can you bake protein bars or balls with Reese’s powders?
A: Definitely! Mixing a scoop of chocolate peanut butter protein powder into protein bar or energy ball recipes can give you that quintessential Reese’s flavor. Get creative with combinations of oats, nut butters, cocoa powder, and other mix-ins.
Conclusion
Finding a protein powder that satisfies your Reese’s peanut butter cup cravings is completely achievable. By looking for key characteristics like chocolate and peanut butter flavor, creamy texture, and sweetness, you can get your candy fix in a protein shake. Pescience Select Peanut Butter Cup strikes the best balance of great Reese’s taste and quality nutrition.
Drinking chocolate peanut butter protein can conveniently curb hunger, promote muscle growth, and power your workouts. Just be mindful of your portions and ingredients. With so many products mimicking that distinctive Reese’s experience, you can keep your sweet tooth in check and your fitness goals on track.