Skip to Content

What meat is best for St Patrick’s Day?


St Patrick’s Day is a cultural and religious celebration held on March 17th every year to honor the patron saint of Ireland, Saint Patrick. It originated as a Catholic feast day but has since evolved into a more secular celebration of Irish culture and heritage. One of the most iconic foods associated with St Patrick’s Day is corned beef and cabbage. However, there are many other types of meat that can also be enjoyed as part of St Patrick’s Day festivities. Choosing the right meat depends on factors like taste preferences, dietary needs, and how much time you want to spend preparing your St Patrick’s Day meal. This article will examine different meat options for St Patrick’s Day to help you determine which is the best choice for your celebration.

Why Meat is Traditionally Eaten on St Patrick’s Day

Eating meat, particularly corned beef, on St Patrick’s Day stems from both religious and cultural traditions. Here are some of the key reasons meat has become strongly linked with this holiday:

  • During Lent, Catholics would not eat meat on Fridays and would instead eat simple, inexpensive foods like cabbage. St Patrick’s Day offers a brief respite when they can enjoy meat again before returning to abstinence for the rest of Lent.
  • Corned beef and cabbage came to be a St Patrick’s Day staple among Irish-American communities in the late 19th and early 20th century when corned beef was an affordable meat choice.
  • Hearty cuts of meat paired with vegetables reflect the kinds of humble, filling meals eaten in Ireland.
  • Eating meat on St Patrick’s Day is seen as a way to celebrate Irish culture and distances the holiday from the religious restrictions of Lent.

So while meat on St Patrick’s Day is not an official requirement, it is a long-standing tradition. Choosing meat you enjoy can help increase your connection with Irish heritage during the festivities.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Meat for St Patrick’s Day

When deciding which type of meat to eat on St Patrick’s Day, here are some factors to take into account:

Taste Preferences

Consider the flavors and textures you and your guests enjoy most. Leaner meats like turkey are milder while fattier cuts like brisket are richer. If you prefer spices, corned beef with pickling spices may be ideal. Don’t feel limited to just one type of meat – serving two or more can please different tastes.

Dietary Restrictions

If you or any guests have dietary limitations, choose meats that accommodate them. Chicken and plant-based meat substitutes work for many vegetarians. For food allergies or intolerance, read ingredient labels carefully to ensure the meat doesn’t contain any problematic foods.

Preparation Time

Some meats require more advanced planning and cooking time than others. Whole brisket, for example, needs 12+ hours to become tender while chicken breasts can cook much quicker. Factor in your schedule so the meat is ready in time for your party.

Cost

Opt for meats that fit your St Patrick’s Day budget. Less expensive cuts like pork shoulder or chicken legs can provide great flavor at a lower per-pound price than things like tenderloin. Watch for meat sales leading up to the holiday too.

Top Meat Choices for St Patrick’s Day

Based on traditional appeal, dietary versatility, and ease of preparation, here are some excellent options to consider when selecting the perfect St Patrick’s Day meat:

Corned Beef

No meat is more iconic for St Patrick’s Day than corned beef. This salt-cured brisket has an unmistakable orange-pink color and distinctive salty, tangy flavor from the curing process. Slow cooking turns the lean meat beautifully tender. Choose a corned beef brisket or opt for simmering corned beef cubes in a stew or with vegetables.

Bacon

This pork product brings smoky, salty, savory goodness to many dishes. Bake bacon strips to crunchy perfection to eat alongside eggs, pancakes, and Irish soda bread for brunch. For dinner, wrap cutlets, chops, or whole chickens in bacon for an Irish take on chicken cordon bleu.

Beef Stew Meat

For a hearty, comforting St Patrick’s Day meal, beef stew is perfect. Browning cubed chuck roast or similar stew beef develops rich flavor. Slowly simmering the meat with veggies like potato, carrot, and cabbage results in a wonderful meal. Adding Guinness or other stout beer adds true Irish flavor.

Pork Shoulder

Pork shoulder roasts, also called pork butt, offer wonderful moistness and flavor. Cook smoked or unsmoked shoulders low and slow until fall-apart tender, then shred or slice the meat for sandwiches. Add a tangy BBQ or Irish whiskey sauce for delicious flavor.

Lamb Leg

As an exceptionally popular meat in Irish cuisine, lamb makes a stellar choice for St Patrick’s Day. A whole boneless leg of lamb roasted until perfectly pink delivers excellent taste and presentation. Carve slices to serve with mint jelly or chimichurri sauce.

Chicken Thighs

Chicken thighs offer convenience, versatility, and lots of juicy St Patrick’s Day flavor. Roast a tray of seasoned thighs or braise them in stout with potatoes and carrots. Shred cooked thigh meat to top nachos, pizza, or fill potato skins for appetizers.

Comparing Nutrition of Top Meats

When selecting your St Patrick’s Day meat, you may want to consider the nutritional profile. Here is a nutritional comparison of 3 ounce servings of top meats:

Meat Calories Fat (g) Protein (g)
Corned Beef 240 15 22
Pork Shoulder 210 13 19
Bacon 120 9 8
Lamb Leg 185 11 22
Chicken Thigh 140 7 15

Key takeaways:

  • Calories range from 120-240 depending on leanness of meat.
  • Fat content varies significantly, from 7g in chicken up to 15g in corned beef.
  • Protein is highest in corned beef and lamb leg at 22g per serving.
  • Chicken thigh is the lowest calorie and fat, making it a healthier choice.

So if limiting calories or fat intake is a priority, opt for leaner meats like chicken or select smaller serving sizes of higher fat meats like bacon or corned beef.

Recipe Ideas for Top Meats

Here are some excellent recipe ideas to inspire your St Patrick’s Day meat cooking:

Corned Beef and Cabbage

  • Slow cook corned beef brisket with cabbage, potatoes, and carrots for a classic dish.
  • Make corned beef hash by dicing cooked corned beef with potatoes and onions.
  • For a Reuben sandwich, pile sliced corned beef with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing between rye bread.

Pork Shoulder

  • Roast seasoned pork shoulder served with roasted potatoes and vegetables.
  • Shred pork shoulder and pile on buns for pulled pork sandwiches with pickles and slaw.
  • Make tacos with shredded pork shoulder, salsa, and cabbage slaw.

Bacon

  • Wrap sausages, meatloaf, pork tenderloin, or chicken breasts in bacon before roasting.
  • Top baked potatoes with crumbled bacon, cheddar cheese, and chives.
  • Cook bacon strips and use crumbled over Irish stew, onion soup, or colcannon.

Lamb Leg

  • Roast boneless leg of lamb seasoned with rosemary and garlic.
  • Make shepherd’s pie with ground lamb meat cooked with veggies, topped with mashed potatoes.
  • Grill lamb kebabs with peppers and onions for an easy appetizer.

Chicken Thighs

  • Braise chicken thighs in Guinness or broth with carrots and parsnips.
  • Grill seasoned chicken thighs for easy weeknight meals.
  • Shred cooked chicken thigh meat and mix with BBQ sauce for sliders or flatbread topping.

The possibilities are endless for cooking tasty St Patrick’s Day meals featuring your favorite meats. Have fun exploring Irish spice blends like seaweed or incorporating stout beer or Irish whiskey into recipes.

Conclusion

When planning your St Patrick’s Day menu, choosing flavorful, well-prepared meat is key to a great holiday feast. Classic corned beef is the most iconic option, but lamb, pork, chicken, and bacon all make wonderful alternatives or additions. Consider taste preferences, dietary needs, cook times, and budget to select your perfect St Patrick’s Day meats. Use the nutrition info and recipe ideas provided to help craft a menu sure to please any gathering while celebrating Irish traditions. Whatever meats you cook up, remember that the most important St Patrick’s Day ingredient is sharing good times and fun with friends and family! Sláinte!