Skip to Content

What is the flavor of the McDonald’s Holiday Pie?

The McDonald’s Holiday Pie is a seasonal dessert that is offered by McDonald’s restaurants during the winter holiday season. The pie has a flaky, buttery crust and is filled with a sweet custard-like filling. Each year, McDonald’s releases the Holiday Pie in a new flavor to excite customers and spread holiday cheer.

Quick Answers

The 2022 McDonald’s Holiday Pie flavor is Eggnog.

The pie is only available for a limited time during the holidays, usually from early November through December.

The filling has a creamy, eggnog-like flavor made with egg custard and warm holiday spices like nutmeg and cinnamon.

It’s a seasonal take on McDonald’s classic baked apple pie.

When is the McDonald’s Holiday Pie Available?

The McDonald’s Holiday Pie first appeared on menus in 1986 and has continued as an annual tradition ever since. The fast food chain only offers the specialty pie for a limited time each holiday season. In 2022, McDonald’s began selling the Eggnog Holiday Pie nationwide on November 16th.

It will remain on menus at participating McDonald’s locations through the holiday season before getting discontinued in late December or early January. The availability timeframe is typically just 6-8 weeks to build hype and excitement around this festive seasonal treat.

What Does the Eggnog Holiday Pie Taste Like?

The Eggnog Holiday Pie for 2022 has a creamy eggnog-flavored custard filling inside a crispy, flaky pie crust. McDonald’s describes it as having a “smooth, creamy eggnog delicately baked into the center of a flaky, buttery crust.”

The filling is made with egg custard and flavored with nutmeg, cinnamon, and other warm baking spices often associated with eggnog. It aims to mimic the creamy, spiced flavor of classic holiday eggnog in pie form. The texture is thick, smooth, and pudding-like.

The pie crust is golden and buttery on the outside and perfectly complements the rich eggnog filling inside. Each bite has a balanced taste of creamy, spiced filling enclosed in a light, flaky crust.

Eggnog Holiday Pie Nutrition Facts

The McDonald’s Eggnog Holiday Pie has around 330 calories per pie. Here is the full nutrition breakdown for one pie (86g):

Calories 330
Fat 16g
Carbs 41g
Protein 5g

What Holiday Pie Flavors Has McDonald’s Offered?

While the Eggnog Pie is new for 2022, McDonald’s has filled its holiday pies with different festive flavors over the years. Here is the list of all previous McDonald’s Holiday Pie flavors since it debuted in 1986:

Year Holiday Pie Flavor
1986 Sugar and Spice
1987 Cherry
1988 Strawberry Rhubarb
1989 Cranberry Orange
1990 Cherry and Pineapple
1991 Pumpkin
1992 Sweet Potato Custard
1993 Cranberry
1994 Peppermint
1995 Peppermint
1996 Pumpkin
1997 Cranberry Apple
1998 Chestnut
1999 Chocolate Custard
2000 Chocolate Custard
2001 Chocolate Custard
2002 Chocolate Custard
2003 Pumpkin
2004 Cranberry Apple
2005 Pumpkin
2006 Pumpkin
2007 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2008 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2009 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2010 Peppermint
2011 Peppermint
2012 Pumpkin
2013 Pumpkin
2014 Pumpkin &
Chocolate Custard
2015 Pumpkin &
Chocolate Custard
2016 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2017 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2018 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2019 Chocolate
Sugar Cookie
2020 Cinnamon Cookie
2021 Cinnamon Cookie
2022 Eggnog

As you can see, McDonald’s likes to alternate between classic pie flavors like pumpkin, peppermint, and chocolate custard. But they also occasionally experiment with unique holiday flavors like cranberry orange, sweet potato custard, chestnut, and now eggnog.

How Does the Holiday Pie Differ from the Regular Pie?

The McDonald’s Holiday Pie sets itself apart from the classic Baked Apple Pie normally available year-round.

Here are some key differences between the seasonal Holiday Pie and regular Baked Apple Pie:

  • Limited Availability – Holiday pie is only sold for 6-8 weeks from November-December
  • Festive Flavors – Holiday flavors like eggnog, while apple is always standard
  • Custard-Style Filling – Holiday fillings are creamy custards instead of appley filling
  • Special Holiday Packaging – Gold and festive holiday-themed box instead of standard packaging
  • Higher Price – Holiday pie usually costs a little more than the regular pie

So essentially, the Holiday Pie takes the same classic baked pastry shell but fills it with new limited-batch custard flavors to excited customers during the festive season.

Should You Try the New Eggnog Holiday Pie?

If you enjoy both the flavor of eggnog and McDonald’s fruit pies, the new Eggnog Holiday Pie is definitely worth trying this season.

It’s great for fans of eggnog who want to enjoy the holiday flavor in dessert form. The creamy, spiced custard filling evokes classic eggnog flavors in a unique way. And it’s encased in McDonald’s signature flaky, golden pie crust.

While availability is limited, it’s a festive seasonal treat to enjoy during holiday gatherings and celebrations through December. The Eggnog Holiday Pie adds some special excitement to the classic McDonald’s dessert lineup for the holidays.

So make sure to stop by McDonald’s this season to get a taste of this cinnamon-kissed, nutmeg-spiced eggnog pie before it disappears from menus in early 2023!

Conclusion

The McDonald’s Holiday Pie is a beloved seasonal tradition featuring fun new flavors every holiday season. For 2022, the fast food chain has decided to fill its Holiday Pie with creamy, spiced eggnog custard for the first time ever. The Eggnog Holiday Pie will be available for a limited time from November 16th through December at participating McDonald’s restaurants. With its balancing act of flaky, buttery crust and rich eggnog filling, it’s a festive new take on classic McDonald’s fruit pies perfect for enjoying during the holidays.