What is the best type of frosting for cupcakes?

Cupcakes are a classic dessert that are beloved by many for their small, personal size and versatility when it comes to flavors and decorations. While the cake itself brings moistness and texture, it’s often the frosting that can really take cupcakes to the next level and help them stand out. The frosting plays a key role not just in adding sweetness and moisture, but in bringing color, texture, and decorative flair. With so many frosting options available, from buttercream to ganache and beyond, it can be difficult to determine the absolute best type of frosting for cupcakes.

Table of Contents

Buttercream

Buttercream is one of the most popular and traditional frosting choices for cupcakes. There are several reasons why buttercream works so well:

Familiar flavor – Buttercream has a sweet, rich, buttery taste that is familiar and appealing to many people.
Soft and fluffy texture – Properly made buttercream has a lush, soft, and fluffy texture that pairs perfectly with cupcakes.
Pipeability – Buttercream can be piped into decorative swirls, rosettes, and other designs to beautifully decorate cupcake tops.

Versatility – Buttercream can be flavored easily, whether infusing it with fruit purees, chocolate, coconut, or other ingredients.
Ability to hold shape – Buttercream keeps its shape well and doesn’t melt, even at room temperature.

There are two main types of buttercream – American and French/Swiss meringue buttercream. American buttercream is made by beating butter with powdered sugar. It comes together more quickly but can be grainy or overly sweet. Swiss meringue buttercream is made by whipping egg whites and sugar into a meringue before incorporating butter. It’s silky smooth but requires cooking the egg whites. So it depends on your priorities whether American or Swiss meringue buttercream is a better choice.

Tips for Perfect Buttercream

To achieve the best flavor and texture for buttercream frosting on cupcakes, keep these tips in mind:

Use high quality, fresh butter. Unsalted butter allows you to control the exact saltiness.
Sift the powdered sugar to eliminate lumps.

Add milk, cream, or other liquid very slowly to get the ideal consistency without thinning it out too much.
Beat the buttercream on high speed for 3-5 minutes to make it light and fluffy.
For extra richness, use equal parts butter and shortening.

Flavor buttercream sparingly so it complements rather than masks the cupcakes.
Refrigerate frosted cupcakes until the buttercream sets, about 30 minutes.

Mastering these best practices will result in buttercream with smooth texture, balanced sweetness, and ideal pipeability.

Cream Cheese Frosting

Cream cheese frosting is another beloved option for cupcakes. It has a trademark tanginess from the cream cheese that pairs especially well with sweeter cake flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet. Benefits of cream cheese frosting include:

Tangy flavor – The cream cheese gives it a distinctive flavor separate from plain buttercream.
Soft texture – The addition of cream cheese makes this frosting extra soft and creamy.

Stability – Unlike buttercream, it holds up well at room temperature without getting too soft.
Muted sweetness – Cream cheese tanginess balances out some of the sugary sweetness.
Easy to flavor – Easily adapts to new flavors by adding fruit, chocolate, spices, etc.

Cream cheese frosting is made similarly to buttercream, by beating cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, and flavorings together until smooth and creamy. It’s important to use full fat cream cheese and beat the frosting enough to eliminate any graininess. Refrigerating unfrosted cupcakes and frosted cupcakes helps the frosting set up nicely.

Tips for Perfect Cream Cheese Frosting

For best results with cream cheese frosting, follow these guidelines:

Allow cream cheese to soften to room temperature before using to avoid clumping.

Use a stand mixer on medium-high speed to beat the cream cheese and butter first before adding other ingredients.
Add powdered sugar 1/2 cup at a time, beating well between additions.
Consider using part shortening instead of all butter for increased stability.

Flavor simply with extracts or food coloring to allow the tangy cream cheese flavor to shine.
Add just enough liquid (milk or cream) to reach the ideal consistency.
Refrigerate unfrosted and frosted cupcakes for the frosting to firm up.

With these tips, you can achieve smooth, tangy, and rich cream cheese frosting that’s perfect for cupcakes.

Ganache

Ganache is an elegant choice for frosting cupcakes. It has a decadent chocolate flavor and ultra smooth, creamy texture. Here’s why ganache shines on cupcakes:

Intense chocolate flavor – Made from chocolate and heavy cream, it delivers deep, rich chocolate taste.

Smooth as silk – When whipped, it has a soft, silky texture unlike any other frosting.
Shiny appearance – Frosted cupcakes have an irresistible glossy sheen.
Customizable – Flavor with different chocolates, extracts, liqueurs, nuts, etc.

Ideal for dipping – Can be thinned out to the perfect consistency for dunking cupcake tops.

Ganache is made by heating heavy cream and adding it to chopped chocolate. The mixture is stirred or blended until smooth. For frosting, it must be cooled and whipped to lighten it. The ratio of chocolate to cream impacts the thickness. Ganache can be tricky to work with but is unmatched in taste and texture.

Tips for Perfect Ganache

Follow these tips for ganache that beautifully finishes cupcakes:

Use high quality chocolate – Go for brands like Callebaut, Valrhona, Guittard, etc.
Cook the cream just until steaming, not boiling.
Let the ganache cool completely before whipping it.

Whip until it triples in volume and resembles soft peaks.
Add extracts or flavorings sparingly.
Use 2 parts chocolate to 1 part cream for ideal thickness.

Refrigerate for at least an hour to allow ganache to set.

Mastering the technique for ganache frosting results in cupcakes with irresistible chocolate richness.

Ermine Frosting

Ermine frosting is a light, fluffy frosting that has a unique texture. Some reasons to consider ermine frosting for cupcakes include:

Light and silky – Has a smooth, silky texture that almost melts in your mouth.
White color – The lack of butter keeps it very white in color.
Holds shape well – While airy, it holds piped shapes and designs relatively well.

Not overly sweet – The mixture of powdered sugar and flour prevents becoming too sugary sweet.
Simple ingredients – Just flour, milk, sugar, eggs, and vanilla makes this budget-friendly.

Ermine frosting gets its distinctive texture from cooked flour mixed into a milk and egg base. Powdered sugar is then whipped in. Cooling the frosting helps it set. Ermine works well on lighter, vanilla cupcakes and can be tinted pastel colors.

Tips for Perfect Ermine Frosting

Follow these guidelines when making and using ermine frosting:

Cook the flour mixture over medium heat for 3-5 minutes to remove any raw flour taste.
Strain the flour mixture through a fine mesh sieve after cooking.

Let the cooked mixture cool completely before adding powdered sugar.
Add powdered sugar gradually to maintain smooth texture.
Whip the frosting on high speed for 5 minutes for fluffiness.

Use milk instead of water for enhanced flavor.
Cool frosted cupcakes in the refrigerator for 30 minutes before serving.

With the proper technique, ermine frosting can give cupcakes an extra light and delicate finish.

Other Frosting Possibilities

While buttercream, cream cheese, ganache, and ermine frostings are top choices for cupcakes, there are several other frosting types that can work well in the right circumstances:

Whipped Cream Frosting

Fresh whipped cream makes a light, melt-in-your-mouth frosting, but it requires refrigeration. Stabilizing it with cream cheese or gelatin can help it hold its shape better. Fresh fruit cupcakes pair nicely with whipped cream frosting.

Marshmallow Frosting

Beating marshmallow creme with butter makes a fluffy frosting that goes well on chocolate cupcakes. It has a sweet flavor and pillowy texture.

Fondant

Rolled fondant gives cupcakes a smooth finish and canvas for elaborate decorations. The taste can be too sweet so it works better on strongly flavored cupcakes. Kids’ parties are a good place for fondant decorations.

Royal Icing

Royal icing dries very hard so it’s ideal for piping details and decoration onto cupcakes. The texture is too hard for frosting whole cupcakes but it works for decorating finished cupcakes.

Comparing Frosting Options

With so many choices available, here is a comparison of some top frosting contenders:

Frosting Type	Flavor	Sweetness	Texture	Pipeability	Hold Shape?	Easy to Make?
Buttercream	Rich, creamy	Very sweet	Smooth, soft	Excellent	Fairly well	Moderately easy
Cream Cheese	Tangy	Less sweet	Fluffy	Good	Very well	Easy
Ganache	Deep, chocolatey	Rich but not too sweet	Silky smooth	Fair	Well	Intermediate
Ermine	Vanilla, delicate	Medium sweetness	Light, fluffy	Moderately well	Fairly well	Moderately easy
Whipped Cream	Creamy, fresh	Slightly sweet	Light, airy	Poorly	Poorly	Very easy

Conclusion

When it comes to the best frosting for cupcakes, you can’t go wrong with classics like buttercream, cream cheese, or ganache. Buttercream delivers timeless flavor and texture with endless versatility. Cream cheese gives you a tangy sweetness that pairs perfectly with cake. And ganache elevates cupcakes with silky chocolate richness. Other frostings like ermine, whipped cream, and fondant offer lightness and opportunities for creativity. Whichever you choose, use premium ingredients and follow best practices for your frosting of choice. With the perfect swirl of sweet frosting, your cupcakes will be sheer delight.