Jello shots are a fun and refreshing party drink that can be made with a variety of liquors. The best liquor to use will depend on your personal taste preferences and the flavor of the jello. When making jello shots, you want to use a liquor that will complement the flavors of the jello without overpowering them. Certain factors like the proof and taste profile of the liquor will impact the final result.
Quick Answers
Here are quick answers to common questions about the best liquor for jello shots:
What is the most popular liquor for jello shots?
Vodka is the most popular liquor used in jello shots, as it has a neutral flavor that works well with sweet jello mixes.
What liquor gets you drunk fastest in jello shots?
Grain alcohols like Everclear with a high proof (around 190 proof) will get you drunk the fastest from jello shots.
What is the best tasting liquor for jello shots?
Flavored liquors like citrus vodka, rum, or peach schnapps often make the best tasting jello shots.
Can you use whiskey or tequila for jello shots?
Yes, you can use whiskey, tequila, gin or other liquors for jello shots. Just be mindful of balancing the flavors.
Factors to Consider
There are a few important factors to take into account when choosing a liquor for jello shots:
Proof of the Liquor
The proof, or alcohol percentage, of the liquor will impact the potency of the jello shots. For a higher alcohol content, choose a liquor with a higher proof around 90-150. For milder jello shots, use a liquor with proof of 70-90. Examples:
- Higher proof liquors good for potent jello shots: Light rum (100 proof), Silver tequila (100 proof), Grain alcohol/Everclear (190 proof)
- Lower proof liquors for milder jello shots: Vodka (80 proof), Gin (80-90 proof), Gold tequila (80 proof)
Flavor Profile
Look for a liquor with a complementary or neutral flavor profile:
- Complementary flavor – Choose a liquor with flavors that will enhance the jello, like coconut rum with pineapple jello or peach schnapps with orange jello.
- Neutral flavor – Vodka, gin or light rum work well as they have mild flavors that won’t overpower.
- Avoid strong flavors – Whiskeys, dark rum or brandy have strong, dominating flavors that may clash.
Sweetness Level
The sweetness of the liquor should match the sweetness of the jello. Sweeter liquors pair better with less sweet sugar-free or low sugar jello:
- Sweet liquors for sugar-free/low sugar jello: Flavored vodka, Peach schnapps, Coconut rum, Irish cream
- Less sweet liquors for regular sugary jello: Unflavored vodkas, Gin, Light or silver rum, Tequila
Best Liquor for Common Jello Shot Flavors
Here are recommendations for the best liquor pairs with popular jello shot flavors:
Vodka Jello Shots
For citrus, berry or other fruity flavors, an unflavored vodka is a safe bet. Pick a vodka like Absolut, Tito’s or Stoli. For extra flavor, use a citrus vodka like lemon or orange.
Tequila Jello Shots
Silver or white tequilas work nicely with brighter, fruitier flavors like strawberry, mango or lime. Reposado or gold tequilas pair well with more subtle flavors.
Rum Jello Shots
Light or silver rum complements fruit flavors like pineapple, orange, or coconut. Spiced rum adds warmth to apple pie or cinnamon jello. Coconut rum enhances tropical fruit flavors.
Gin Jello Shots
With its herbaceous flavors, gin pairs well with fruit forward flavors like citrus, berries, and melon. A fruit-infused gin can also lend complementary flavors.
Whiskey Jello Shots
Bourbon whiskey can work nicely with Southern flavors like peach, apple pie, caramel or pecan. Irish whiskey enhances Baileys and coffee flavored jello.
Schnapps Jello Shots
Peppermint, peach, or citrus schnapps enhances similar fruit or sweet flavors. Use an unflavored vodka along with schnapps to balance the sweetness.
| Jello Flavor | Best Liquor Match |
|---|---|
| Cherry | Vodka, Gin, Peach Schnapps |
| Strawberry | Vodka, Tequila, Peach Schnapps |
| Margarita | Tequila, Orange Liqueur |
| Pineapple | Rum, Coconut Rum, Vanilla Vodka |
| Watermelon | Vodka, Gin, Rum |
| Peach | Peach Schnapps, Vodka, Bourbon |
| Island Punch | Rum, Peach Schnapps |
Tips for Making Jello Shots
Once you’ve selected the ideal liquor, here are some tips for mixing up amazing jello shots:
Use a High Proof Liquor
The alcohol will start to solidify the jello, preventing it from setting properly. Use a liquor with a higher proof around 90-150.
Dissolve Jello First
Prep the jello according to package directions. Let it fully dissolve in boiling water first before adding cold liquor.
Add Liquor to Taste
Start by adding half of the total liquor you want, mixing well. Then add more liquor to taste for your preferred potency.
Test Consistency
Test the thickness by drizzling a small amount on a plate. It should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon.
Use Cold Liquor
Make sure you add very cold liquor so the jello sets up fast and firm.
Pour into Smaller Molds
Use mini cups or shot glasses. Avoid large molds, as it will take longer to set up properly.
Refrigerate for at Least 4 Hours
Give the jello shots at least 4 hours minimum to fully set up before serving.
Store Extras in Layers
To store extra jello shots, layer them in a dish separated by plastic wrap so they don’t stick together.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make jello shots without alcohol?
Yes, you can make virgin jello shots by replacing the liquor with an equal amount of juice, soda or water.
How long do jello shots last?
Properly stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, jello shots can last for 4-5 days.
What is the best way to remove jello shots from the molds?
Run the molds briefly under warm water to help loosen the jello shots. Gently release around the edges with your finger if needed.
Can you freeze jello shots?
It’s best not to freeze jello shots, as they will become mushy once thawed. Refrigerate for storage instead.
Why didn’t my jello shots set up properly?
The liquor may have too low a proof or have been added when the jello was too warm. Always use cold liquor and let jello fully dissolve first.
Making Jello Shots for a Party
When making jello shots for a party or gathering, keep these tips in mind:
- Make jello shots in advance so they have time to set up – at least 4 hours, or the night before.
- Offer a variety of fun shapes, colors and flavors. Mold them in reusable silicon shapes.
- Use festive themes with layers, swirls, and garnishes like sprinkles.
- Provide clear plastic shot cups and small spoons for easy serving.
- Keep jello shots chilled right up until serving time for best texture.
- Use waterproof labels and markers so guests can write their names on cups.
- Serve jello shots alongside other drinks and finger foods.
- Use premium liquor and limit to 1-2 jello shots per guest until effects are known.
Creative Jello Shot Recipes
Vodka Lemon Drop
Ingredients: Lemon Jello, Vodka, Sugar, Water, Lemon Juice
Long Island Iced Tea
Ingredients: Tea Jello, Vodka, Rum, Gin, Tequila, Triple Sec, Lemon Juice
Cherry Cheesecake
Ingredients: Cherry Jello, Cream Cheese, Vanilla, Condensed Milk, Vodka
Margarita Madness
Ingredients: Margarita Jello, Tequila, Orange Liqueur, Lime, Salt
Pina Colada
Ingredients: Pineapple Jello, Coconut Rum, Pineapple Juice, Coconut Flakes
Strawberry Daiquiri
Ingredients: Strawberry Jello, Rum, Strawberries, Lime Juice, Sugar
Moscow Mule
Ingredients: Ginger Beer Jello, Vodka, Lime Juice, Ginger Ale, Mint
Sangria
Ingredients: Red Wine Jello, Brandy, Citrus Fruits, Apple Slices
Conclusion
Jello shots are a fun and creative way to enjoy your favorite spirits. While vodka may be the most popular, you can also use rum, tequila, gin or other liquors. Pick a liquor with the ideal proof and taste profile to complement the flavors of your jello. Prep the jello properly and add chilled liquor for best results. With the right liquor match and preparation method, you can whip up amazing jello shots for any occasion!