When roasting vegetables in the oven, you have two main options for lining your baking sheet: parchment paper or aluminum foil. Both options work well, but they each have some differences that may make one better than the other depending on what you’re cooking. In this article, we’ll look at the pros and cons of using parchment paper versus foil for roasting veggies to help you decide which is best for your needs.
Quick Answer
For most vegetables, parchment paper is the better choice for roasting over foil. Parchment allows for more even browning, fewer burnt edges, and an easier cleanup. Foil can reflect heat unevenly leading to hot spots that burn vegetables, and it can react with acidic ingredients. However, foil does prevent leaks and is useful for messier foods. Overall, parchment paper leads to better results for crisp, caramelized roasted veggies.
Advantages of Parchment Paper
Here are some of the benefits of using parchment paper instead of foil when roasting vegetables:
Promotes Even Browning
Parchment paper allows for air flow under the vegetables which leads to more even exposure to the hot air in the oven. This means the vegetables brown more evenly on all sides instead of just the parts touching the pan. With foil, the foil can create a barrier preventing steady air circulation.
Minimizes Burned Edges
The air flow that parchment paper enables helps prevent the edges of vegetables from getting overdone and burned. The perforations in parchment reduce hot spots that form and burn vegetable edges. Foil has no perforations, so edges are prone to burning.
Won’t React with Ingredients
Foil can react to acidic ingredients like tomatoes, lemon juice, or vinegar when exposed to high oven heat. This can cause metallic tastes to leach into the vegetables. Parchment paper is non-reactive and won’t alter flavors.
Makes for Easy Cleanup
Parchment paper prevents vegetables from sticking to the pan, making cleanup as easy as tossing away the parchment. With foil, vegetables can stick and leave behind hard burnt bits requiring scrubbing to remove.
Can Be Reused
If the parchment didn’t get too dirty, it can be rinsed, dried, and reused, making it more eco-friendly. Foil cannot be reused.
Often Pre-Cut to Fit Baking Sheets
Many brands of parchment paper come pre-cut to exactly fit half-sheet pans and quarter-sheet pans. This makes it easy to line a baking sheet. Foil would need to be cut to size.
Advantages of Aluminum Foil
Here are some benefits of using foil over parchment for roasting vegetables:
Contains Messes
Roasting messy, juicy vegetables like tomatoes or mushrooms can lead to juices leaking all over the oven. Foil contains these leaks better than parchment. The juices will pool on top of the foil instead of running all over.
Makes Tenting Food Easier
Foil is better for tenting or covering food while roasting to trap in steam. Parchment is floppy and can’t hold up as a cover. Tenting with foil helps cook food faster.
Reflects Heat
The reflective surface of foil bounces heat around the food which can accelerate cooking times. This isn’t always best though as too much concentrated heat from foil causes hot spots.
Crunchy Texture
Some foods like potatoes or crispy skinned fish get an extra crispy base when roasted on foil. The foil draws out moisture for a crisper exterior texture.
No Need to Adjust Oven Racks
Foil can be molded to a pan to create a tight fit. Parchment works best fitted under oven racks. Foil eliminates any need to adjust racks to accommodate parchment.
Factors that Impact Performance
A few factors that can determine whether parchment or foil performs better for roasting specific vegetables include:
Moisture Content
Wet vegetables like mushrooms, tomatoes, and zucchini release a lot of moisture when roasted. Foil holds in steam better than parchment. But drier vegetables like potatoes, carrots, and beans don’t need as much steam held in.
Preparation Method
If vegetables are cut into small, uniform pieces, parchment works well. Large, irregular cuts are harder to evenly roast on parchment. Foil suits large vegetable chunks better.
Other Ingredients
Parchment is best for roasting coated vegetables or veggie medleys with oil or other acidic ingredients that could react with foil. Plain vegetables can be roasted fine on foil.
High Oven Heat
Roasting at very high temps above 425°F is best done on parchment paper. Foil can overheat, burn, and release metals at high temps. Parchment withstands heat better.
Cooking Time
Quick roasting uses foil’s heat conducting abilities best. Long roasts over 40 minutes have more even results with parchment paper.
Tips for Roasting Vegetables
Follow these tips for delicious roasted veggies, whether using foil or parchment paper:
Toss in Oil and Seasonings
Coating vegetables in a bit of olive oil or other cooking oil along with desired seasonings ensures even flavor and browning. Sprinkle on seasoning blends, herbs, spices, salt, and pepper.
Spread in a Single Layer
Arrange vegetables in a single layer on the lined pan without overcrowding for the best texture. Some touching is fine, but too crowded inhibits caramelization.
Roast at 400-425°F
Most vegetables roast best and develop that delicious caramelized flavor between 400-425°F. Adjust time for thicker/denser veggies.
Toss Periodically
For even cooking, toss the vegetables gently a couple times during roasting to rotate which sides face up and down.
Pull When Browns and Tender
Roast vegetables until fork tender and the edges are nicely browned. The time varies from 15-45 minutes depending on the veggies.
Best Vegetables for Roasting
Almost any vegetable can be roasted for delicious flavor. Some of the best options include:
Root Vegetables
– Potatoes
– Sweet potatoes
– Carrots
– Parsnips
– Beets
– Turnips
Cruciferous Vegetables
– Brussels sprouts
– Broccoli
– Cauliflower
– Cabbage wedges
– Kohlrabi
Alliums
– Onions
– Shallots
– Garlic
– Leeks
Vine Vegetables
– Zucchini
– Yellow squash
– Eggplant
– Bell peppers
– Cherry tomatoes
Others
– Mushrooms
– Asparagus
– Green beans
– Okra
– Corn
Comparing Parchment Paper and Foil
To summarize the differences:
| Parchment Paper | Aluminum Foil |
|---|---|
|
|
Conclusion
For most vegetables, parchment paper is the better choice for oven roasting. It cooks food more evenly, lets moisture escape, and prevents burning better than foil. Foil is still useful for containing juicy foods, tenting to trap steam, and getting a crispy base on some foods like potatoes. But overall, parchment paper lined baking sheets will result in deliciously caramelized roasted veggies with nice color and crispy edges. Give parchment a try for your next sheet pan meal of roasted vegetables!