Skip to Content

Halloween Eyeball Punch

As the witching hour approaches, there’s no better excuse to unleash your creativity and concoct a spellbinding array of treats that’ll leave your guests screaming with delight. And what better way to cast a culinary curse than with this eerie eyeball punch? This bewitching brew combines the juiciest fruity flavors with ginger ale, creating a potion that’s as unsettling in appearance as it is delicious to drink.The pièce de résistance is, of course, the eyeballs themselves – crafted from longan fruits and blueberries. And why stop there? Add some plastic spiders or other creepy crawlies for an added layer of frightfully fun! It’s the perfect potion to serve at your Halloween shindig, and when you’re done, be sure to conjure up some more spooky favorites like these pot de creme desserts, panna cotta eyeballs, or any of our other hauntingly good recipes. This bruschetta, for instance, is a real howler – just don’t say we didn’t warn you!

Why You’ll Love Halloween Eyeball Punch

When planning a Halloween party, simplicity is key when it comes to recipes. This spooky season is all about indulging in sweet and spooky treats without breaking the bank with complex preparations. Fortunately, this fruity punch recipe checks both boxes – it’s quick to make and devilishly delicious! The beauty of this concoction lies in its versatility, allowing you to tailor it to your party’s tone by opting for a non-alcoholic version or adding your favorite liquor for an adults-only gathering. Ginger ale provides a crisp base, while the combination of Western and Eastern fruits creates a thrilling flavor experience that’s sure to be a hit with both kids and adults alike.

How to Make Halloween Punch


To craft this unique beverage, follow these steps. Start by mashing the blackberries in a pitcher to release their natural sweetness and texture. Next, combine the mashed blackberries with the preserves, fruit juices, and ginger ale. Stir well to ensure everything is fully incorporated. The next step is to create the ‘eyeballs’. Simply place a frozen blueberry inside each longan fruit to add a pop of color and whimsy. Finally, add any desired garnishes, such as gummy bats or worms, and serve the drink cold.

Substitutions and Variations


Feel free to experiment with different fruit juices – apple, pineapple, orange, and cranberry are just a few examples. Ultimately, the choice is yours, so select the ones you enjoy the most. However, keep in mind that some of these juices may contain added sugar, which could alter the drink’s sweetness level to your taste.If you prefer a slight kick, consider adding a splash of alcohol or swapping out the ginger ale for your preferred soda. Alternatively, add a few drops of red food coloring to give the punch a bolder hue.

What to Serve with Halloween Eyeball Cocktail


When it comes to crafting delicious and spooky Halloween appetizers, the options are endless. While you may have your own unique ideas for what to serve at your party, some popular choices include mummy stromboli, black charcoal pizza, and other creative concoctions that will surely delight your guests.

How to Store this Halloween Party Favourite


When preparing this cocktail ahead of time, be sure to store it in the refrigerator. Only add the ice just before serving, as this will help preserve its refreshing qualities. Alternatively, you can freeze the mixture, but keep in mind that the ginger ale’s fizziness won’t translate well when thawed. For optimal enjoyment, it’s best consumed fresh.

Spooky Eyeball Punch FAQs

While longan fruit is an acceptable substitute for lychees, you may also consider using lychee eyeballs instead. This recipe is versatile enough to accommodate either option, as both fruits share similarities such as their small size, white color, sweetness, and Asian origin. The difference in appearance and taste between the two fruits is minimal, allowing you to experiment with whichever one suits your preference.In terms of serving, you have the freedom to choose between a large punch bowl or a pitcher. A punch bowl would be the traditional vessel for this Halloween-themed concoction, but using a pitcher is also a viable option if that’s what you prefer. To keep things refreshing and chilled, consider adding ice cubes directly to the punch or placing them in serving glasses before pouring the eyeball punch over them.

Halloween Eyeball Punch Bowl Recipe

Halloween Eyeball Punch

Bella Bucchiotti brings the spooky spirit to your Halloween party with this bewitching eyeball punch. A refreshing and eerie concoction, it’s perfect for a crowd of ghosts and goblins. This recipe takes mere minutes to prepare, making it an ideal addition to any haunted gathering. With a preparation time of just 15 minutes, you’ll be sipping on some monster mash in no time.

Instructions

To create the fruity concoction, begin by extracting the juice from the longans and setting it aside. Next, combine the blackberries into a large pitcher, mashing them with a wooden spoon to release their natural flavors. Add the blackberry preserves and mix until well combined. Then, introduce the cherry juice, white grape juice, cranberry cocktail juice, and reserved longan juice, stirring until smooth. Give the mixture a gentle stir as you add in the ginger ale. To create the playful eyeballs, place a single frozen blueberry inside each longan segment. Serve the punch with or without these edible ‘eyeballs’ added to individual glasses or the pitcher itself.