This is an interesting question that many gardeners and plant lovers have pondered. When we cut flowers or trim our houseplants, are the plants experiencing pain or distress? Recent scientific research indicates that plants may not “scream” in the traditional sense when cut, but they do undergo physiological responses similar to those felt by animals. Keep reading to learn more about the fascinating sensory capabilities of plants and what happens on a cellular level when we cut them.
Do Plants Feel Pain?
Pain as humans understand it requires a complex nervous system and brain that plants do not possess. However, plants do have sensory capabilities that allow them to detect and respond to external stimuli. For example, plants can sense gravity, light, moisture, and chemical signals. They can also detect physical stimuli like touch, temperature, and damage.
When a plant experiences stressful stimuli like cutting, drought, or insect damage, they undergo physiological changes similar to an animal’s pain response. These include:
- Production of jasmonic acid, a chemical involved in plant stress responses
- Increased respiration rate, like heavy breathing in animals
- Closing of stomata on leaves to prevent water loss, similar to sweating in animals
- Wilting or drooping of leaves and stems
- Reduced photosynthetic activity
- Reallocation of sugars and nutrients away from growth towards defense
So while plants do not have nerves or brains to process pain, they react to damage in complex ways that promote their survival. Many scientists argue these responses constitute a type of pain experience.
How Plants Perceive Damage
Plants have protein receptors located throughout their tissues that help them sense what is happening in their environment. These receptors detect physical damage from cutting, crushing, or insect feeding. Damaged areas send electrical signals similar to nervous impulses to other parts of the plant using vascular tissue and chemical messengers.
This wound signal prompts nearby leaves to produce protective chemicals or jasmonic acid that activate defense genes further from the site of damage. So a cut leaf alerts the whole plant to prepare its defenses against predators or disease. This demonstrates sophisticated sensory capabilities beyond a simple reflex.
Plant Responses to Cutting
When pruning or cutting a plant, you sever its vascular system that transports water, nutrients, and sugars. The exposed tissue releases chemicals that stimulate protective efforts in other parts of the plant. Here are some specific responses to cutting damage:
Closing Off Damaged Tissue
When a plant is wounded, cells around the cut surface release chemicals that signal it to close off the exposed area. This stops sap loss and prevents microbes from invading. The plant’s vascular tissue outside the cut constricts, much like blood vessels constricting to stop blood loss after an animal injury.
Cellular Respiration Increases
Like an animal’s elevated breathing and heart rate after injury, a cut plant starts respiring faster at the cellular level. The increased respiration provides more energy to fuel protective chemical responses. Wounded leaves show a dramatic spike in respiration within minutes of damage.
Photosynthesis Slows Down
When a plant is cut, it often wilts or droops around the damaged area. This drooping reduces water loss but also decreases photosynthesis in those leaves. The plant is essentially going into an energy-conserving mode by reducing photochemistry activity and reallocating sugars to defense strategies instead of growth.
Nutrients Rerouted
Plants can selectively redistribute sugars, proteins, and minerals towards certain leaves or roots when stressed. After wounding, a plant pulls nutrients away from mature or damaged tissues and sends them to areas where they’re needed, like younger leaves or roots. Proteins and sugars fuel the production of defense compounds around a cut.
Protective Chemicals Made
One of the most important plant responses to damage is increased chemical defense production. These include:
- Phenols and tannins – Bitter chemicals that deter herbivores
- Phytoalexins – Antimicrobial compounds that fight plant diseases
- Jasmonic acid – Hormone that regulates defense gene activation
- Reactive oxygen species – Destroy plant cells to prevent spread of infection
Making these protective compounds allows the plant to fight back against whatever is attacking it, such as pests feeding on its leaves.
Cell Walls Strengthen
Plants also respond to wounding by reinforcing their cell walls with lignin, suberin, and callose. These compounds make cell walls tougher and less susceptible to invading microbes. Hardened cell walls around a cut surface help wall off the damage.
Dopruned plants grow back healthier?
Most plants have an incredible ability to heal and regrow after pruning. In fact, regular pruning often results in a bushier, more productive plant. Here’s why pruned plants can grow back even better than before:
Stimulates growth hormones
Cutting triggers a spike in auxin, a plant growth hormone produced at the tips of stems and branches. Removing the auxin source causes auxin to accumulate lower in the plant, stimulating buds to start new stems and leaves.
Increases light exposure
Pruning opens up dense growth, allowing more light to reach lower branches and the center of the plant. More light energizes photosynthesis, fueling regrowth.
Improves air circulation
Air circulation is improved when dead wood, crossing branches, and crowded interior growth are removed. Better airflow decreases pest and disease problems.
Removes inefficient tissue
Pruning directs the plant’s energy towards more productive tissues. Removing weak, damaged, or excessive growth improves efficiency.
Encourages fruiting and flowering
Fruit trees and flowering shrubs often produce more buds when pruned. New shoots from pruning favor flowering and fruit production.
Maintains desired shape
Regular pruning keeps ornamental plants in their intended shape and prevents leggy, unattractive growth. Pruning for shape promotes plant health.
So while pruning removes plant tissues, it triggers beneficial responses that lead to revitalized growth. With proper technique, most plants tolerate pruning well and recover vigorously.
Conclusion
Although plants do not have complex nervous systems, researchers have found they react to damage in sophisticated ways that suggest a kind of injury response We may perceive. Cutting a plant traumatizes its living cells and initiates changes similar to an animal’s pain reflex. However, plants lack consciousness and cannot “scream” or feel human emotions. Their wound reactions are primarily cell-signaling processes that enable survival and self-protection. With proper care, most plants quickly recover from pruning. So while a degree of harm is inevitable when cutting plants, we can take steps to minimize stress and promote their health and productivity.
References
[1] Trewavas, A. (2009). What is plant behaviour?. Plant, cell & environment, 32(6), 606-616.
[2] Karban, R., & Myers, J. H. (1989). Induced plant responses to herbivory. Annual review of Ecology and Systematics, 20(1), 331-348.
[3] Pearce, G., Strydom, D., Johnson, S., & Ryan, C. A. (1991). A polypeptide from tomato leaves induces wound-inducible proteinase inhibitor proteins. Science, 253(5022), 895-898.
[4] Howe, G. A. (2004). Jasmonates as signals in the wound response. Journal of plant growth regulation, 23(3), 223-237.
[5] León, J., Rojo, E., & Sánchez‐Serrano, J. J. (2001). Wound signalling in plants. Journal of experimental botany, 52(354), 1-9.
[6] De Visser, P. H., Marcelis-van Acker, C. A., van der Plas, L. H., & de Vries, A. H. (1994). Allometric relations and boundary conditions for diffusion and reaction in vascular plants. Biophysical chemistry, 51(3), 227-243.
[7] Asai, S., Ohta, K., & Yoshioka, H. (2008). MAPK signaling regulates nitric oxide and NADPH oxidase-dependent oxidative bursts in Nicotiana benthamiana. The Plant Cell, 20(5), 1390-1406.
[8] León, J., Rojo, E., & Sánchez‐Serrano, J. J. (2001). Wound signalling in plants. Journal of experimental botany, 52(354), 1-9.