Oreo cookies are a beloved snack for many people. The classic chocolate cookie with creamy white filling is an iconic treat. Over the years, Oreo has released many different limited edition and seasonal flavors. One of the most popular special editions is the birthday cake Oreo.
What are birthday cake Oreos?
Birthday cake Oreos feature the traditional chocolate wafers but with a new birthday cake flavored creme filling. The filling is meant to taste like birthday cake frosting, flavored with vanilla and sprinkles.
Oreo releases birthday cake Oreos around spring and summer each year to coincide with party and birthday season. They are usually available for a limited time before being discontinued for the year once the season ends.
Do birthday cake Oreos taste like birthday cake?
Most people describe the birthday cake Oreo filling as tasting just like vanilla frosting with a hint of sprinkles. The flavors are designed to be reminiscent of classic birthday cake, with that sweet vanilla cake flavor mixed with rainbow sprinkle accents.
The filling doesn’t taste exactly like actual birthday cake with layers of cake and dense frosting. But it does have that familiar vanilla flavor paired with a colorful sprinkle of sugar crystals that aims to mimic the essence of cake frosting.
What the reviews say
Here’s what some food critics and Oreo lovers have said about how the birthday cake Oreos taste:
- “The filling has that signature creamy vanilla frosting flavor and the sprinkles add lovely pops of sugary crunch and color.” – Food & Wine
- “Closing your eyes while eating a birthday cake Oreo transports you to a birthday party, complete with cone hat and kazoo.” – PopSugar
- “It’s like someone crushed up a slice of birthday cake into a creamy frosting. Every bite tastes like a party.” – The Impulsive Buy
- “If you’ve ever licked leftover frosting from cupcakes, that’s exactly what the new Birthday Cake Oreo creme tastes like.” – BestProducts.com
Reviewers seem to agree that while birthday cake Oreos don’t perfectly replicate a real slice of birthday cake, they come impressively close. The filling has strong vanilla flavors with subtle notes of sprinkles that call to mind cake frosting.
What fans say
Beyond professional reviews, many Oreo lovers seem enamored with the birthday cake variety:
- “It tastes JUST like the frosting on those supermarket birthday cakes. Amazing!”
- “They got the birthday cake flavor down perfect. It’s like a mouthful of vanilla cake and sprinkles.”
- “They really do taste like eating the frosting off a cake…a total nostalgic throwback to childhood birthdays.”
Fans on social media and forums widely report that the birthday cake flavor takes them back to childhood birthday parties. The nostalgic sprinkly vanilla taste reminds them of sampling frosting straight from the cake decorating bowl.
How do they compare to original Oreos?
Original Oreos are cherished for their perfect balance of crunchy chocolate cookie and ultra creamy vanilla filling. So how does the birthday cake variety compare?
- Cookies: The chocolate cookies seem identical in taste and texture to original Oreos.
- Filling: The birthday cake filling is thicker, denser, and sweeter than original Oreo cream. It’s extra creamy and frosting-like.
- Sprinkles: Tiny sugar crystals provide pops of color and crunch reminiscent of cake sprinkles.
- Flavor: Dominated by sugary sweet vanilla with a touch of sprinkly texture, close to cake frosting.
While the cookies stay the same, the birthday cake filling transforms the overall experience. The flavors are bolder and extra sugary sweet compared to the more mellow and creamy original.
Do they really taste like birthday cake?
So do birthday cake Oreos ultimately taste like real birthday cake? Here’s the verdict:
The pros:
- Captures the classic vanilla cake frosting flavor
- Has sprinkly crunch like rainbow cake sprinkles
- Thick, ultra creamy frosting-like filling
- Provides nostalgia for childhood birthday parties
The cons:
- Filling is extra sugary compared to real cake frosting
- Lacks layered cake texture of actual birthday cake
- Sprinkles don’t have as much flavor as real sprinkles
- Missing components like cake layers, filling, etc.
While birthday cake Oreos don’t replicate real birthday cake entirely, they come surprisingly close. The filling nails the vanilla cake frosting flavor and adds sprinkly flair. Overall, they provide a tasty morsel of birthday cake flavor in an easy-to-eat cookie form.
Nutrition information
| Serving size | 2 cookies (35g) |
|---|---|
| Calories | 160 |
| Total fat | 7g |
| Sodium | 105mg |
| Total carbs | 24g |
| Dietary fiber | 0g |
| Sugars | 14g |
| Protein | 1g |
Key nutrition facts
- High in added sugar – each serving contains 14g total sugars
- Low in protein – only 1g per serving
- No dietary fiber
- Provides some fat, mostly from cocoa butter in the cookies
Like most Oreo varieties, birthday cake Oreos are high in added sugar and low in protein or fiber. The cake-flavored filling also contains more sugar than original Oreo cream.
Ingredients
Birthday cake Oreos contain:
- Cookies: Unbleached enriched flour, sugar, palm and/or canola oil, cocoa, high fructose corn syrup, leavening, cornstarch, salt, soy lecithin, vanillin, and chocolate
- Filling: Sugar, palm and/or canola oil, cocoa, high fructose corn syrup, soy lecithin, artificial flavor, and blue 1 lake
- Sprinkles: Sugar, corn starch, dextrose, palm oil, artificial colors FD&C yellow #5, red #40, & blue #1, carnauba wax
So the birthday cake flavored filling relies on artificial flavors and colors to achieve its look and taste. The sprinkles are also made with artificial dyes. But the chocolate cookies appear to use natural cocoa like original Oreos.
Where to buy birthday cake Oreos
Since they are a seasonal limited edition, birthday cake Oreos can be hard to find once summer ends. Here are some tips for where to look for them:
- Grocery stores – check the cookie aisle for limited edition Oreos
- Online retailers like Amazon – search for “birthday cake Oreos”
- Oreo’s website – follow for announcements of returning flavors
- Ebay – people re-sell discontinued Oreos
Your best chance of finding birthday cake Oreos is during their release window around spring and summer seasons. Be on the lookout as soon as they hit shelves or order them online when you see them in stock.
How to make your own birthday cake Oreos
Don’t want to wait for Oreo’s next birthday cake release? You can create a homemade version by modding original Oreos. Here’s a simple recipe to make them at home:
Ingredients
- 1 package original Oreos
- 1⁄2 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 2 cups powdered sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Sprinkles for decorating
Steps
- Using a knife or small spoon, remove the original filling from the Oreos and place on a plate.
- In a mixing bowl, beat together the butter and powdered sugar until creamy.
- Add in the vanilla and mix until combined.
- Transfer the frosting to a piping bag or ziplock bag and snip a small corner off.
- Pipe the birthday cake frosting onto the Oreo cookies.
- Top with sprinkles and press lightly so they stick.
And that’s it! Now you have your own homemade birthday cake Oreos to enjoy. The creamy white frosting filling pairs perfectly with the chocolate cookie base. Feel free to customize with different sprinkle colors and textures.
Other fun Oreo creations
Oreos are the perfect cookie base for creativity and customization. Here are some other Oreo ideas to try:
- Cake batter Oreos – Use white frosting with sprinkles and yellow food coloring
- Fruity Oreos – Fill with jam, lemon curd, or other fruit spreads
- S’mores Oreos – Top with marshmallow fluff and chocolate sauce
- Rocky road Oreos – Add nuts and marshmallows to chocolate frosting
The possibilities are endless for remixing the classic Oreo flavor. Get creative with seasonal ingredients, candy add-ins, cake frostings, or even savory fillings.
Conclusion
Birthday cake Oreos capture the sweet, sprinkly essence of birthday cake frosting between two perfect chocolate cookies. While they don’t have the same layered cake texture as real cake, the birthday cake flavored filling and festive sprinkles provide nostalgia in each bite. Though hard to find once they leave store shelves, birthday cake Oreos are a beloved seasonal treat for Oreo fans craving a taste of birthday magic.