The short answer is yes, you can absolutely substitute tequila for vodka in jello shots. While vodka and tequila are different spirits with their own unique flavors, they can generally be swapped 1:1 in cocktail recipes.
Differences Between Vodka and Tequila
Before looking at using tequila in jello shots specifically, let’s briefly go over some of the main differences between vodka and tequila:
- Vodka is distilled from grains or potatoes, while tequila is distilled from the blue agave plant
- Vodka is generally flavorless and odorless, while tequila has notes of agave and citrus
- Vodka can be made anywhere in the world, while tequila can only be made in certain regions of Mexico
- Vodka is usually around 40% ABV (80 proof), while tequila is usually around 38-40% ABV (76-80 proof)
The key similarities are that they are both clear, distilled spirits and have a relatively similar alcohol content. This makes them roughly interchangeable for cocktail mixing purposes. The main difference you’ll notice in the final drink is that the tequila will impart a bit more flavor.
Tequila in Jello Shots
Turning to jello shots specifically, tequila works just as well as vodka as the alcoholic base:
- Tequila has a similar alcohol content to vodka, so the end result will be just as boozy.
- The flavors of tequila like agave and citrus can actually enhance many jello shot flavors nicely.
- Tequila is no more or less likely to “break” the gelatin matrix than vodka.
Here are some recommended tequila jello shot flavor combos:
- Classic Lime Jello Shots – The citrus flavors of blanco tequila pair perfectly with lime jello.
- Margarita Jello Shots – Use gold or reposado tequila and add a bit of orange liqueur for a margarita twist.
- Paloma Jello Shots – Try grapefruit jello with blanco tequila and a splash of grapefruit soda.
- Pineapple-Jalapeno Jello Shots – Reposado tequila and pineapple jello with a slice of jalapeno is a fun combo.
Feel free to get creative with your own tequila jello shot flavor ideas too!
Tips for Making Tequila Jello Shots
When substituting tequila for vodka in any jello shot recipe, keep these tips in mind:
- Use a 1:1 ratio – For every 1 cup vodka, use 1 cup tequila
- Stay within 38-40% ABV – Avoid using extra añejo or crema de tequila as they have a much higher alcohol content
- Skip the salt and limes – You don’t need to rim the glasses with salt or serve limes since the tequila flavor comes through
- Give it time to set up – Tequila can sometimes take a bit longer to fully gel compared to vodka
Also be sure your jello shots are fully set and firm before serving. Soaking gelatin properly and allowing enough setting time in the refrigerator is key to get that nice firm jiggle texture.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best tequila to use?
For a basic substitute in jello shots, blanco (white/silver) tequila works great and provides a crisp, clean agave flavor. Reposado or añejo tequilas can also be used for a more aged, oaky flavor.
Do you need to adjust the amount of liquor?
No adjustment is needed – use a 1:1 ratio to substitute tequila for vodka. As long as you stay within the 38-40% ABV range for tequila, the amount of liquor needed will be the same.
Will tequila jello shots taste very different from vodka ones?
They will taste a bit different due to the inherent flavors of tequila coming through. But if you use complementary jello flavors, the tequila notes can enhance the overall flavor profile nicely.
Conclusion
Tequila is a great substitute for vodka in jello shots, as it provides a similar alcohol content and gelatin-setting ability. The agave and citrus notes of tequila can also nicely complement many classic jello shot flavors. Just use a 1:1 ratio when substituting tequila for vodka, stick to blanco or reposado tequila, and allow a bit of extra setting time. With the right tequila and jello pairing, your shots are sure to deliver that fun, buzzy jiggle everyone loves!