Many new moms wonder if they can exclusively pump breast milk instead of directly nursing their baby. There are a few key considerations when deciding between nursing and exclusively pumping.
Is pumping as good as nursing?
Both nursing and exclusive pumping provide breast milk for your baby. However, there are some differences between the two methods:
- Nursing allows for physical closeness and skin-to-skin contact between mom and baby that pumping does not provide.
- Nursing helps establish bonding and attachment between mother and child.
- The act of nursing stimulates milk production and release of oxytocin and prolactin that pumping does not replicate.
- Nursing is more efficient at removing milk from the breast than pumping.
- Pumping requires cleaning and maintaining pump equipment.
- Nursing is free while pumping requires purchase of a quality breast pump.
While pumping can provide breast milk for your baby, most lactation experts recommend aiming to directly nurse your baby when possible. Nursing provides health and immunity benefits that are unique to the mother-baby connection.
Is exclusive pumping realistic?
Exclusively pumping around the clock to provide breast milk is possible but challenging. Some key points about exclusively pumping:
- You must pump very frequently, at least every 2-3 hours, to maintain milk supply.
- Pumping is time consuming, especially with set up, cleaning, and bottle feeding the expressed milk.
- Maintaining an adequate milk supply requires diligence and commitment.
- Growth spurts or changes in baby’s feeding patterns can disrupt pumping output.
- Exclusive pumping is mentally and physically taxing for most mothers.
While some moms can successfully pump exclusively, most find it unsustainable for longer than a few months. Having realistic expectations of the demanding pumping schedule helps make an informed decision.
Reasons moms consider exclusively pumping
There are several common reasons that mothers consider exclusively pumping instead of nursing directly:
- Baby has latch difficulty or refusal: Babies who struggle with properly latching may benefit from short-term pumping and bottle feeding while addressing the underlying issues.
- Need to monitor milk intake: For premies or babies with weight gain concerns, some moms pump to measure exact ounces consumed.
- Comfort level: Some moms feel shy or uncomfortable nursing in public or front of family so prefer to pump milk.
- Nipple pain: Pumping can provide relief when mothers experience nipple trauma, friction, or changes in sensitivity.
- Separation from baby: Mothers who are away from their baby for work or other reasons often pump to provide breast milk.
- Convenience: Pumping allows other caregivers to bottle feed while mom is away or resting.
Even when mothers plan to exclusively pump, most find that some direct nursing sessions are still helpful for milk supply and bonding.
Tips for exclusive pumping
If you decide to exclusively pump, the following tips can help make it more manageable:
- Invest in a high-quality double electric breast pump to save time.
- Limit pumping sessions to 10-15 minutes to avoid decreased output.
- Massage breasts during pumping to help empty more efficiently.
- Purchase extra pump parts so there is always a clean set ready to go.
- Stay hydrated and eat nutritious snacks to support milk production.
- Pump every 2-3 hours around the clock, even overnight.
- Set reminders and schedule pumping sessions to stay consistent.
- Consider renting a hospital-grade pump if able.
- Get support from family or postpartum doulas to allow more rest.
Even with the best routines, pumping is time consuming and limits other activities. Accepting help from loved ones can make long-term exclusive pumping more sustainable.
Supplementing when pumping
Many moms who exclusively pump find they need to supplement feedings with formula to meet baby’s nutritional needs. Common reasons for supplementing include:
- Baby is still acting hungry after feeding pumped breast milk.
- Pumping output is gradually declining, signaling decreased milk supply.
- Growth spurts result in a temporary need for more milk than available.
- Mom needs longer stretches of uninterrupted sleep than pumping overnight allows.
- Illness or solidi foods introduction impacts pumping frequency and output.
Supplementing with some formula takes pressure off needing to pump milk for every single feeding. Speak with your pediatrician if you need guidance determining when and how much to supplement breast milk feedings.
Weaning from exclusive pumping
Over time, many moms who exclusively pump will want to transition back to some direct nursing or wean from pumping altogether. Some tips for weaning from exclusive pumping include:
- Gradually replace 1-2 pump sessions per day with nursing sessions.
- Begin dropping the overnight pumping session first when ready.
- Slowly stretch time between pumping sessions rather than removing full sessions.
- Use a comfortable and gradual approach over 4-6 weeks for the most success.
- Use massage, cool compresses, sage, and tight fitting bras to relieve engorgement.
- Only express enough milk for comfort if overly full, avoiding full emptying of breasts.
- Consider donated milk or formula to meet needs once milk supply regulates.
Make sure to monitor engorgement and plugged ducts as you wean pumps. Slowly dropping pumping sessions prevents discomfort from sudden weaning. Remember fed is best, whether by nursing, pumping, or formula.
Pros and cons of exclusive pumping
To summarize the key pros and cons of exclusively pumping:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
Conclusion
Exclusively pumping to feed your baby breast milk instead of directly nursing is an option some mothers choose. However, the time commitment, effect on milk supply, and isolation from baby make this choice overwhelming for many moms. Seeking support and anticipating the challenges of exclusive pumping allows an informed decision. Supplementing pumped milk with some nursing sessions or formula is also a viable feeding approach. Remember that a fed baby is best, whether at the breast, through pumping, or with formula. Focus on your self-care and don’t hesitate to reach out for help.